Christmas Gifts for Dogs That Are Actually Worth Buying

Let’s be honest: our dogs don’t need another pile of Christmas junk just because it’s December. But a few healthy treats, a toy they’ll actually enjoy, or something that makes everyday life a little better? Now we’re talking!

I put together this list of Christmas gifts for dogs with a few things in mind: quality, usefulness, and whether I’d genuinely spend my own money on them. Some have already earned Athena’s approval (and believe me, she’s not exactly gentle with her belongings), while others caught my attention after a little research.

Whether you have a furry cuddle bug, an energetic ball of chaos, or a dog who simply enjoys the finer things in life, you’ll find some great ideas here worth putting under the Christmas tree for them!

Personally, I’m not interested in buying something just because it’s trendy, heavily marketed, or looks cute in a product photo. I pay attention to ingredients, materials, quality, and whether something offers genuine value for the money. And most importantly, whether it’s actually suitable for the dog receiving it. Because the last thing anyone needs is more stuff taking up space in the house.

So, what’s actually worth putting under the tree? Let’s start with something most dogs will never turn down.

Jump to:

• Dog treats worth getting
• Edible chews
• Toys that make playtime better
• Enrichment gifts for busy brains
• Practical gifts they’ll use all year

This website uses referral links. Please read our disclosure policy for more information.

Dog treats worth getting

Let’s start with the good stuff. And by good stuff, I mean treats made with ingredients you can actually get excited about.

I’m quite particular about what I feed Athena. Reading ingredient labels is practically a hobby of mine (yes, I know, I need to get out more 😂). I tend to favor simple, meat-forward recipes over treats with long ingredient lists full of fillers, flavorings, and extras dogs don’t particularly need.

That doesn’t mean every ingredient I’d skip is automatically bad for every dog. But when choosing training treats or just-because treats, I want something that brings a little more to the table.

Freeze-dried meat treats usually get my attention. Recognizable ingredients, minimal processing, and a flavor that makes most dogs forget you even exist for a moment? Now we’re talking. And yes, the stinkier ones tend to get a particularly enthusiastic reception around here. Ask Athena. 😂

A quick note:
Many freeze-dried meat treats are made from raw ingredients. Follow the manufacturer’s handling and storage instructions, wash your hands after handling, and use the same hygiene precautions you’d use with raw pet food.

Here are a few dog treats worth considering:

Icelandic+ — fishy treats for dogs who love seafood

If your dog enjoys fish, Icelandic+ is definitely a brand worth checking out. We regularly buy several of their treats, including Whole Fish Sprats, Fishy Bites, and Cod & Salmon Combo Bites. I usually have at least a couple of varieties in Athena’s treat bag.

What I like about them:

• A nice selection of fish-based treats, offering something different from the usual chicken and beef.
• Air-dried fish treats, made and packed in Iceland.
• Simple options without unnecessary extras, depending on the variety.

The sprats are definitely the most memorable of the bunch. They’re whole, air-dried fish with just one ingredient: sprat. Crunchy, simple, and definitely aromatic. Athena considers that a feature, not a drawback. 😂

They also happen to be my most valuable bargaining chips when it’s time to trim Athena’s nails. I lay out the fish payment in advance because apparently, nail care requires a compensation package around here. 🙃

Vital Essentials — one of my absolute favorites!

Why I like it:

• A broad selection of freeze-dried animal proteins, including beef, chicken, turkey, duck, rabbit, salmon, and minnows.
• Several single-animal-protein options, which can be useful when you’re looking for a particular protein.
• Transparent information about ingredient sourcing, processing, and food-safety practices.
• Different bag sizes, so you can try a new protein without committing to a giant bag.
• Made in the USA.

I particularly like the simple ingredient lists. The Minnows, for example, contain just minnows, while the Diced Salmon is another single-ingredient option. The Salmon Bites contain salmon and mixed tocopherols, a preservative. That’s the sort of labels I like seeing when I’m shopping for a healthy dog treat.

And the minnows deserve a special mention, because they’re low-odor!

I also like the Rabbit bites and Duck bites, for adding some variety. Athena refuses to eat either protein raw but happily devours them freeze-dried. Go figure! Honestly, any of the bite varieties I’ve tried have been a hit. They’re also small and easy to use as training rewards.

Primal — chicken and pumpkin for something different

Why I like it:

• Chicken and pumpkin, with goat milk in the recipe.
• No corn, wheat, soy, or artificial preservatives.
• Small, bite-sized pieces.
• Made in the USA

The Chicken & Pumpkin bites are a nice change from the straight-up meat treats. Athena loves pumpkin, so this combination definitely caught my attention. I like the idea of having a little variety beyond the usual meat-only options.

Primal also makes chicken recipes with peanut butter and banana, but pumpkin gets my vote. It’s a little less ordinary.

Instinct Freeze-Dried Raw Meals — my treat-bag alternative

Here’s a little trick: I often buy Instinct Freeze-Dried Raw Meals instead of conventional treat bags. They’re technically complete freeze-dried dog food, not treats, but I use them as rewards, for indoor “find it” games, and occasionally as a little snack between meals. (Athena is almost always ready for another meal. 😂)

Why I like them:

• Larger bags offer more product than many conventional treat bags.
• Small pieces that are easy to use as rewards.
• Meat, organs, fruits, and vegetables in the recipe.
• Formulated as complete and balanced food, with added vitamins and minerals.
• Made in the USA.

I alternate between Cage-Free Chicken, Grass-Fed Beef, and Grass-Fed Lamb recipes, and all are a hit with Athena. Another option is a Pollock recipe, which we haven’t tried yet.

For Athena, who’s around 55 pounds, I usually buy the larger 25-ounce bags (the lamb comes in a slightly smaller 24-ounce bag). The 14-ounce size is a good way to try it first.

If you’re looking for a Christmas gift for a food-motivated dog, this is a practical alternative to the usual little bags of treats. It’s something they’ll enjoy long after the decorations come down.

One important distinction: this is a complete food that I’m repurposing as treats, not a product specifically formulated to be fed as occasional treats. Account for the extra calories when adding it to your dog’s daily food intake.

Edible chews

Sometimes the best gift is something your dog can happily work on for a while. For edible chews, my pick is bully sticks.

Made from dried beef pizzle (yes, that’s the less glamorous name for a bull’s penis), bully sticks are single-ingredient chews with a satisfying texture and a strong smell that dogs tend to love. Humans? Not always so much. 😂

They come in different lengths and thicknesses, making it easier to find an option suited to your dog’s size and chewing style. They’re generally better suited to dogs who enjoy working on an edible chew than to serious power chewers like Athena, my Belgian Malinois, who would turn one into a rather expensive snack in no time. (Sometimes the honest answer is that there isn’t a magic edible chew that will keep every power chewer busy for an hour…)

One brand worth looking at is Farm Hounds. The company highlights its sourcing from U.S. family farms and its pasture-raised, grass-fed cattle, along with its approach to processing without irradiation. Its bully sticks are also marketed as low-odor, which is a welcome bonus if you’ve ever opened a particularly pungent bag of these things. They’re pricier than many standard options, but if you want to put something a little more special under the tree, they’re worth considering.

As always, choose an appropriate size, supervise your dog, and remove the chew when it becomes small enough to swallow.

Toys that make playtime better

A good toy doesn’t have to be fancy or expensive. Sometimes a simple plush toy is all it takes to make a dog’s day. Other dogs, however, need something a little more substantial. (Athena, I’m looking at you.)

Here are two great dog toy gift ideas for Christmas, depending on your dog’s play style.

Plush toys & dog toy bundles

If your dog enjoys soft toys, Christmas is a great excuse to stock up! You can find assorted plush-toy bundles on Amazon that include several toys, and best of all, they cost a whole lot less than what you’d spend buying the same number individually. They’re a fun gift, especially for dogs who enjoy carrying toys around, tossing them, squeaking them, or simply having something soft to cuddle with.

Just keep your dog’s habits in mind. These bundles are best suited to dogs who play gently with plush toys. If yours likes to rip everything apart like Athena, you might end up with more stuffing on the floor than toys under the tree. 😂

Toys for power chewers

For dogs who need something tougher, I’d look at the black KONG Extreme toys. They’re made with KONG’s specially formulated rubber and designed for dogs with strong chewing habits. We’ve gotten several over the years for Athena.

Personally, I prefer durable rubber toys over hard nylon chew toys. Rubber has more give, which is one of the reasons I gravitate toward it for serious chewers. That doesn’t mean it’s indestructible, though. Even Athena can eventually shred a rubber toy, so regular inspection and supervision are still important.

Enrichment gifts for busy brains

Snuffle mats worth considering

I love snuffle mats and puzzle toys. Athena, on the other hand, thinks they’re things to eat. So neither is likely to end up under our Christmas tree. 😂

But that doesn’t mean I don’t have favorites! I spent quite a bit of time comparing different options, looking beyond the product photos to find designs, sizes, and features I’d actually want in an enrichment toy for my own dog. These are the ones that stood out and made my shortlist.

A colorful option for small and medium dogs

This bone- and flower-shaped snuffle mat caught my eye because it manages to be colorful without looking like someone emptied a box of crayons onto it. 😂 The orange, yellow, green, and brown tones are cheerful but not overwhelming, and I particularly like the variety of fabric folds and textures. It looks thoughtfully designed rather than overly busy or tacky. It’s a nice option for smaller and medium-sized dogs who enjoy sniffing out their treats.

A larger mat with plenty of textures for big dogs

Another option for dogs who need more room to forage is this generously sized mat, measuring approximately 39.4 x 23.6 inches. It has bright colors and a variety of textures, giving dogs several places to investigate and sniff around. If you have a larger dog or simply want a more substantial enrichment mat, this one is definitely worth considering.

A more understated option for dogs of all sizes

If you prefer muted colors and don’t want another brightly colored dog accessory taking over your living room, this one is absolutely worth a look. It comes in gray, blue, and soft pink color options, with two sizes available: 22 x 38 inches (medium) and 38 x 38 inches (large). I also like that roughly half of that mat offers a flatter, easier foraging surface, making it an interesting option for dogs who aren’t quite ready for a more complicated sniffing challenge. And honestly? It’s one of the better-looking snuffle mats I’ve come across.

An interactive puzzle for food-motivated dogs

If your dog enjoys working out how to get to the good stuff, the Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Lickin’ Layers puzzle is an interesting option.

This three-layer puzzle has more than 100 treat compartments. Dogs have to spin the layers to uncover the food, making it a little more involved than simply sniffing around a mat. You can use dry kibble and treats or spread soft foods across the layers for a different kind of challenge. It can also double as a slow feeder if your dog tends to inhale meals.

I like that it combines a few different activities in one design: finding food, figuring out how the layers move, and licking up softer foods. It’s a fun Christmas gift for food-motivated dogs who enjoy having a little job to do.

There’s also a puppy version of the Lickin’ Layers available, designed with younger dogs in mind.

Practical gifts they’ll use all year

A soft, washable blanket for home and travel

Sometimes the best Christmas gifts for dogs are the simple things they’ll use every day. This particular dog blanket is one of those purchases I genuinely love.

I bought the gray version for Athena after coming across so many positive reviews, and I’m happy to say they didn’t disappoint! The blanket is soft, lightweight, made from polyester, and washes really well. We use it at home and take it along when we travel, giving Athena a familiar, comfortable place to settle wherever we go.

I also like that it comes in four sizes and several color options, so you can choose something that suits both your dog and your home. The neutral gray was an easy choice for me, but there are other colors available if you’d prefer something different.

It’s not an extravagant dog gift, but it’s practical, comfortable, and something I can genuinely recommend from experience.

Paw protection for winter walks

If you spend a lot of time outdoors with your dog, a little paw protection can come in handy, especially during winter. Natural Dog Company’s PawTection is a wax-based paw protectant that we actually use and like.

Its formula contains plant oils, butters, and waxes, including organic sunflower oil, mango butter, candelilla wax, and carnauba wax. I like that it comes in a convenient stick, making application fairly straightforward without having to scoop balm out of a tin.

We have the 2 oz size, which is a nice way to try the product without committing to a larger container. Just keep in mind that it may be a little small if you have a larger dog or plan to use it frequently.

It’s not the most exciting present to unwrap on Christmas morning, perhaps, but it’s definitely a useful addition to a dog’s winter gear!

A few final thoughts

And that’s my take on Christmas gifts for dogs that are actually worth buying. No random gadgets, no questionable treats, and definitely no buying something just because it comes in festive or bright packaging. 😂

I’d much rather spend a little more on something well-made, thoughtfully designed, and genuinely enjoyable for the dog than fill a stocking with things that end up forgotten in a corner (or destroyed in approximately 4.7 minutes).

Of course, every dog is different. What works wonderfully for one might be completely wrong for another. You know your dog’s habits, preferences, and chewing style better than anyone, so keep those in mind when choosing.

And if you’re shopping for a dog who happens to be a Belgian Malinois like Athena… well, good luck. You’ll need it. 😂

Here’s to fewer impulse buys, better products, and a very happy dog this Christmas!